Dwarven Forge alternatives: 3D dungeons without the price tag
Dwarven Forge terrain runs from $111 to $369 a bundle and their Kickstarters raise millions. Here's what you're paying for, and the cheaper ways to get a 3D dungeon.
Dwarven Forge makes the best-looking dungeons in the hobby. Dwarvenite terrain is durable, the sculpts are genuinely good, and a fully built dungeon on a table is a spectacle that photographs beautifully and makes players lean in.
The demand is not in question either. Caverns Deep! raised over $3.3 million on Kickstarter; Dungeon of Doom over $3 million. Their store lists bundles from around $111 for an unpainted dungeon and cavern starter up to roughly $369 for painted sets.
If you want the object, buy the object. What follows is for everyone doing the maths and finding it does not work.
The three costs, not one
Money. The obvious one. A starter bundle covers a starter’s worth of dungeon — a few rooms and corridors. Covering the range of locations a campaign actually visits means several sets, and the number climbs fast.
Storage. This is the cost nobody mentions and the one that ends collections. A set large enough to build varied dungeons is a serious amount of shelf, and it needs sorting between sessions or you spend the first twenty minutes hunting for corner pieces. People underestimate this consistently.
Setup time. Building a large layout is commonly fifteen to thirty minutes. You either do it in advance — which means knowing exactly where the party will go — or the table watches you build. And when they go somewhere you did not plan, you cannot rebuild mid-session.
That last point is the real functional limit. Physical terrain rewards a DM who knows the route. It punishes improvisation, which is most of what actually happens at a table.
What modular printed tiles do instead
The appeal of terrain is modularity — build the dungeon you are running, not a fixed printed map. Tiles keep that and drop the three costs.
Lay out in a minute. Deal the rooms and corridors as the party explores. The dungeon appears as they walk it, which is arguably better than presenting a fully built layout that reveals its own shape before anyone enters.
Reconfigure mid-session. The party goes somewhere unplanned, you deal different tiles. No rebuild, no apology.
Store flat. A folder, not a shelf.
Reprint anything. A tile gets bent or a drink lands on it; print another.
The honest trade is that it is flat. Tiles do not have walls you can see over, and there is no denying a built Dwarven Forge dungeon looks better in a photograph.
Getting height cheaply, if you want it
If the appeal is genuinely the 3D-ness rather than the modularity, there are middle routes:
Printed terrain. If you own a 3D printer, terrain STLs cost resin rather than retail — see 3D printing D&D miniatures, which covers the same workflow.
Foam and card. Walls cut from foamboard and stood on a printed map give you height for pennies. Crude, effective, and infinitely customisable.
Minis do more work than walls. A well-populated map with paper minis or standees reads as three-dimensional at table level far more than most people expect.
Or go the other way entirely
The other route to spectacle is a screen. A cheap TV laid flat under perspex, with a map displayed at one inch per grid square, gives you something terrain cannot: any location, instantly, at no marginal cost.
Sewers this week, an airship next, a burning city after that. No storage, no build time, and animated maps if you want them. Our guide to battlemaps on a TV or projector covers the build, and the tabletop display tool handles scaling.
That setup costs less than one painted Dwarven Forge bundle and covers every location a campaign will ever visit.
The decision
Do you want a hobby, or do you want dungeons?
If building and painting terrain is a pleasure in itself — and for a lot of people it genuinely is, on a par with painting miniatures — then buy it and enjoy it. It is not a rational purchase and it does not need to be.
If what you want is a dungeon on the table each week that matches wherever the party actually went, tiles or a screen do that better, faster and for far less.
A reasonable hybrid: printed tiles or a screen for the weekly dungeons, and one Dwarven Forge set for the campaign’s centrepiece location. The final confrontation gets the full build; the other forty sessions do not need it.
For laying out the dungeon itself, the free random dungeon generator will produce a layout, and traps and puzzles cover what to put in the rooms once you have them.
Frequently asked questions
- How much does Dwarven Forge terrain cost?
- Their store lists bundles from around $111 for an unpainted dungeon and cavern starter up to roughly $369 for painted sets. Their Kickstarter campaigns have been among the largest in tabletop, with Caverns Deep! raising over $3.3 million and Dungeon of Doom over $3 million.
- Is Dwarven Forge worth the money?
- For the object, genuinely yes — the material is durable, the sculpts are excellent and a built dungeon on the table is a spectacle nothing else matches. As a way of covering the locations a campaign needs, it is very expensive per square foot and slow to set up.
- What is the cheapest way to get a 3D-looking dungeon?
- Modular printed dungeon tiles. You print rooms and corridors, lay them out to match the dungeon you are running, and rearrange them between encounters. You get the modularity of terrain without the storage, the cost or the build time.
- How long does it take to set up modular terrain?
- Building a full dungeon from physical terrain takes real time — commonly fifteen to thirty minutes for a large layout, and you either build it in advance or the table waits. Printed tiles lay out in a minute and reconfigure mid-session.
- Do you need 3D terrain to run a good dungeon?
- No. A flat battlemap with a grid conveys everything the rules need. 3D terrain adds spectacle and tactile appeal, which is a genuine pleasure, but it does not change how the encounter plays.
- What about storing terrain?
- Storage is the underrated cost. A collection large enough to build varied dungeons takes up serious shelf space and needs sorting between sessions. Printed tiles stack flat in a folder and cost nothing to store.
Keep reading
From the shop
Battlemaps, spell cards, and magic item cards, ready to print.
Browse MakeMythic on Etsy →