How to run Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden
A DM's guide to running Rime of the Frostmaiden: pacing Ten-Towns, using the secrets, keeping the cold a threat, and getting the party to Ythryn without a slog.
Rime of the Frostmaiden is the best horror-adjacent campaign D&D has published, and the one most likely to die in chapter one.
The setup is excellent: a valley under permanent night, ten small towns competing for dwindling resources, a goddess who has decided winter should be forever, and a party who each carry a private secret. The problem is that chapter one hands you dozens of quests with no ordering, no urgency and no structural reason to leave — and then expects a campaign to develop out of it.
Solve that, and the rest of the book largely runs itself.
Prep the frame, not the content
Before session one, decide three things and write them on one page:
Which towns exist for you. Ten is too many. Pick four the party will actually visit — Bryn Shander as the hub, plus three with quests you like — and let the other six exist as names, rumours and destinations they hear about. You can always promote one later.
What the clock is. The book gives you a slow-burn threat. Give yourself a visible one: something that gets worse every few sessions whether or not the party acts. A town that loses its supplies. A duergar patrol seen closer each week. The Rime does not need a doom counter, but it needs a direction.
How the party knows each other. In a survival setting, “you all meet in a tavern” is worse than usual. Handle it at Session 0 alongside the secrets.
Making the secrets pay off
The character secrets are the campaign’s best mechanic and the most commonly wasted. Each player gets a private hook — an obligation, a flaw, a hidden goal. Handed out and then ignored, they are a novelty that gets forgotten by session three.
Two habits fix it:
Plant one opportunity per player per arc. Not a resolution — an opportunity. Someone who recognises them. A document with the wrong name on it. A rumour that touches their secret sideways. The player decides whether to bite.
Let secrets collide. The moments people remember are when one player’s secret creates a problem for another’s. Read all of them before session one and look for the two that rub against each other, then engineer a scene where both are in the room.
Keeping track of who knows what is the real work here — a note-taking system that has a line per player per session is worth more in this campaign than in most.
Running the cold without drowning in bookkeeping
Extreme cold is the setting’s signature and its most common failure mode. Run it strictly by the hour and the campaign becomes a constitution save simulator. Ignore it and the valley may as well be temperate.
The middle path is to make cold a planning constraint:
- Travelling overland without proper gear is a real decision with a real cost. Roll for it.
- Being outdoors at night without shelter is dangerous. Roll for it.
- A fight that runs long in the open starts to hurt. Mention it, then roll for it.
- Walking between two buildings in Bryn Shander is not a saving throw.
The result is players who buy furs, plan routes, argue about whether to push on, and treat shelter as a resource. That is the experience the cold is for. Our guide to cold weather and survival rules covers the mechanics in more detail, and the travel and weather tool will generate conditions if you would rather not roll them yourself.
Chapter by chapter, briefly
Ten-Towns. Five or six quests, chosen to touch the party’s secrets. Establish the duergar as a background threat early. End it when the pattern is established, not when the quest list is empty.
Sunblight. The campaign’s first proper dungeon and a welcome change of texture after open-ended errands. Do not rush it — this is where the party stops being errand-runners.
Destruction’s Light and the chardalyn dragon. A set piece. Give it a whole session and let a town genuinely suffer.
Grimskalle and Auril’s Abode. The tonal peak. The trials work well as written; the cold here should be the worst it has been all campaign.
Caves of Hunger and Ythryn. The turn from survival horror to buried-city exploration is abrupt by design. Lean into it — Ythryn is a wonder, not a dungeon, and it rewards players who explore rather than clear rooms.
Making it physical
This campaign benefits more than most from props. The party spends its time in a place that is defined by scarcity and cold, and physical objects — a supply notice, a town sign, a letter that arrived weeks late — communicate that faster than description.
The MakeMythic bundle covers the campaign end to end with 803 printable pieces — Ten-Towns signs, notices and menus, quest handouts, letters, character secret and goal cards, 78 campaign and battle maps, NPC portrait cards, paper mini standees, VTT tokens, monster stat cards, spell scrolls, magic item cards and cold-weather references, in English, Italian, French, German and Spanish.
The secret and goal cards are the standout for this specific campaign, because handing a player their secret as a physical card they keep is meaningfully different from telling them in a Discord DM.
Common failure modes
Chapter one never ends. The most common way this campaign dies. Set yourself a session cap before you start.
The secrets evaporate. Track them explicitly or lose them.
Everything is grey. A valley of snow and dark needs contrast — a warm tavern, a lantern-lit market, a hot meal described in detail. Horror needs something to threaten.
Auril is abstract. She works best when the party experiences her influence long before they meet her. Cold that behaves like it is paying attention.
If it goes well
Rime of the Frostmaiden ends somewhere very few campaigns go: a flying wizard city buried under a glacier, full of magic nobody has touched in centuries. Getting a party there with their secrets resolved and their furs still on is one of the more satisfying arcs in published D&D.
For running other published campaigns, our guides to Curse of Strahd and The Wild Beyond the Witchlight cover the same ground for very different tones.
Frequently asked questions
- What levels does Rime of the Frostmaiden cover?
- The campaign runs from level 1 to around level 12, taking characters from small-town troubles in Ten-Towns through Auril's strongholds and into the buried city of Ythryn. Most groups spend a disproportionate amount of that time in chapter one.
- Is Rime of the Frostmaiden good for new DMs?
- It is challenging for a first campaign. Chapter one is ten towns' worth of loosely connected quests with very little structure imposed on them, which is a lot of improvisation and prep management. A more linear adventure like Lost Mine of Phandelver is a gentler start.
- How do the character secrets work?
- Each player is given a private secret at the start — a hidden goal, obligation or flaw tied to the setting. They are excellent for player investment but only pay off if you actively plant opportunities for them. Left alone, most secrets are never mentioned again after session two.
- How cold should the cold be?
- Cold enough that the party plans around it, not so cold it becomes a tax. Use extreme cold checks at genuine exposure points — overland travel, a failed shelter, a fight that goes long outdoors — rather than every hour. The threat should shape decisions, not generate paperwork.
- Should I use the Ten-Towns quests as written?
- Use them as a menu, not a checklist. There are far more than any group needs. Pick five or six that connect to your players' secrets, seed the rest as rumours, and move to chapter two before the pattern of small-town errands wears out.
- How long does Rime of the Frostmaiden take to run?
- Typically a year or more of weekly play, and longer if chapter one runs unchecked. Trimming Ten-Towns is the single biggest lever on total campaign length.
Keep reading
From the shop
Battlemaps, spell cards, and magic item cards, ready to print.
Browse MakeMythic on Etsy →